Don't let this unassuming place fool you. The Detroit Pizza here is outstanding with a capital O. Great crust sides and bottom quality ingredients. Make the trip to Algonquin
Pizza Restaurant
Pizza Pushers
4.8(385 reviews) Algonquin
About Pizza Pushers
Pizza Pushers is a pizza restaurant at 644 S Main St in Algonquin that serves Detroit style pizza in regular and large sizes. Its menu also lists Psycho Sticks, a Caesar salad and desserts, and the restaurant serves beer. It offers dine-in and carryout and is closed on Mondays and Tuesdays.
Services
Detroit style pizza
Dine in
Carryout
Psycho Sticks
Caesar salad
Cheesecake, tiramisu and chocolate fudge cake
Beer
Good to know
- Service options
- Dine in and carryoutSource: pizzapushers.pizza
- Specialty
- Detroit style pizza, sold in regular and large sizesSource: pizzapushers.pizza
- Also on the menu
- Psycho Sticks, Caesar salad, cheesecake, tiramisu and chocolate fudge cakeSource: pizzapushers.pizza
- Drinks
- Beer and Mexican CokeSource: pizzapushers.pizza
- Days closed
- Monday and TuesdaySource: Google Business Profile
- Accessibility
- Wheelchair accessible entrance, restroom and seatingSource: Google Business Profile
Reviews
Google reviews rated four stars and above. The 4.8-star rating reflects all 385 Google reviews.
Loved absolutely everything about this place. Thank you, Jamie!! I have so many amazing thoughts and at the same time I'm just speechless! Thank you, please keep it up!!
The pizza tasted great. My only other rhoughts would be that the,toppings are a little skimpy and for the size of the pizza its rather expensive. A regular size pizza is almost bot enough for 2 people and its 22-24 bucks.
Response from the ownerThanks for the honest feedback! 🍕 We’re glad to hear the pizza tasted great — that’s the big one!
We hear you on the toppings and the price. We’re always looking for ways to make sure there’s plenty of good stuff on every pie without making the pizza need a second mortgage. 😂
We really appreciate you giving us a try and sharing your thoughts. We’ll keep working on making those pizzas bigger, better, and even more satisfying!
Today was my first time trying pizza from here, and honestly I loved the pizza. I had the “Winston Wolf” it was delicious. I love a good pizza with vodka sauce and this did not disappoint. The nice gentleman that took my order was super helpful and gave me tips to better enjoy the pizza. Also they have a cool dining area as well really love the movie posters that decorate the place it gives a very nostalgic look. I will definitely be back regularly.
Response from the ownerThe Winston Wolf is always an excellent choice! We’re pumped you loved the vodka sauce and our vibe.
Thanks for the stellar review, Sandy — we’ll be ready for you when you’re back for round two! 🍕🤘
I tried this place for the first time. Heard about it from many friends. I got to say, it is hands down the best Detroit style pizza I have had. The crust was out of this world good, as well as the fresh ingredients. I had the Hellraiser pizza, which if you like spicy pizza it was phenomenal. I will be trying many more of the pizzas they offer. As a horror movie fan, I really liked the theme of the inside. If you are a pizza lover like myself you have to put this on your list to try. Can't wait to go back!
Response from the ownerGlad the pizza lived up to the hype and the horror vibes didn’t scare you away!
Thanks for the killer review, David— now comes the hard part: choosing your next pizza victim. 🤘🍕
Pizza was soooo good! We got the Hellraiser and it is our new fave pizza! The guy at the counter was super nice, recommended the larger size for 3 hunger people and did not steer us wrong! Def check this place out, worth it.
Response from the ownerNow THAT’S what we like to hear, Mirna! 🍕🔥
The Hellraiser claiming the #1 spot?! We’ll try not to let it go to its head. 😂 Thanks for the excellent review!
Delicious pizza with quality ingredients. You can tell the recipe was crafted with skill and intention. The pizza and customer service combine to form a compelling product that can only be the result of an immense passion for and pride in the food they make. A true 10/10, no notes.
Response from the ownerMark, thanks for rocking with us and supporting what we do. We’ll keep bringing the heat, the flavor, and the pizza! 🤘🍕
Best Detroit style we've ever had! Didn't realize this place existed, until our realtor gave us a gift certificate. Food was delicious, staff was very friendly. The Winston Wolf and Hellraiser pizzas were PERFECT. Very happy with the whole experience. We will be back!!!
Response from the ownerOkay, first of all, shout-out to your realtor for the elite-level recommendation! 😂🍕
“Best Detroit style we’ve ever had” is a pretty serious compliment, and we’re trying really hard not to let it go to our heads.
Thanks so much for the awesome review and for giving us a shot.Can’t wait to have you back, Matt!